Is Toxic Positivity Harming You? Uncovering the Dark Side of the ‘Good Vibes Only’ Culture”

Is toxic positivity harming you?

The self-help industry is booming. Everywhere you look, there’s a new book, podcast, or influencer promising a better, happier version of yourself. While there’s a lot of good advice out there, not all self-help content is helpful—some of it can actually do more harm than good. One of the most problematic aspects is toxic positivity—the insistence on being positive no matter what. In this post, we’ll dive into what toxic positivity is, how it can hurt us, and how to strike a healthy balance between optimism and realism. We will uncover the dark side of the good vibes only culture.

What is Toxic Positivity?

Toxic positivity is the belief that one should maintain a positive mindset and dismiss negative emotions, regardless of the situation. It’s the “good vibes only” approach that often dismisses genuine feelings of pain, anger, or sadness. According to a study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, suppressing negative emotions can have long-term negative effects on mental health, contributing to stress, anxiety, and even physical health issues (Gross & Levenson, 1997).

While positive thinking is generally beneficial—research suggests that optimistic people tend to be healthier and more resilient—it becomes harmful when it invalidates real struggles and silences authentic emotions (American Psychological Association, 2021).

How Does Toxic Positivity Manifest?

Thoughtful

Toxic positivity can show up in different ways, from social media hashtags to well-meaning advice from friends and family. Here are some common phrases and scenarios that highlight this issue:

• “Look on the bright side!”

• While it’s good to find silver linings, this phrase can dismiss someone’s pain, implying that it’s not valid to feel upset.

• “Just be happy!”

• Happiness isn’t a switch you can flip on command. For people dealing with depression or anxiety, this advice can feel frustrating and isolating.

• “Everything happens for a reason.”

• While this statement can be comforting for some, it can minimize trauma and suffering, making the person feel as though they shouldn’t be struggling at all.

Why is Toxic Positivity Harmful?

Despite its seemingly good intentions, toxic positivity can have real negative impacts:

1. Suppresses Genuine Emotions

Emotions

• Studies show that bottling up emotions can lead to increased stress and mental health issues. According to a study by Harvard Medical School, repressing emotions can increase the risk of heart disease and hypertension (Santos et al., 2019).

2. Creates Unrealistic Expectations

• Constantly aiming for positivity creates an illusion that life should be happy all the time, setting people up for disappointment. Life’s ups and downs are natural, and experiencing negative emotions is part of a healthy psychological process (Psychology Today, 2020).

3. Reduces Empathy and Connection

Empathy

• When people are told to “stay positive” in response to serious issues like grief or illness, it can make them feel misunderstood and alone. Empathy involves recognizing and validating others’ feelings, not minimizing them with forced positivity (Greater Good Science Center, 2018).

4. Discourages Seeking Help

• Toxic positivity can make people feel ashamed of their struggles, discouraging them from seeking professional help. According to a report by the National Institute of Mental Health, stigma around expressing negative feelings is a major barrier to seeking therapy.

The Psychological Science of Balanced Positivity

Therapy

Psychologists emphasize the importance of “emotional agility,” a term coined by Dr. Susan David, a Harvard Medical School psychologist. It involves acknowledging and accepting all emotions, both positive and negative, without judgment. Emotional agility is about navigating life’s challenges with a healthy mix of self-compassion and honesty (David, 2016).

Dr. David suggests that allowing yourself to feel “negative” emotions like sadness, anger, or frustration can actually enhance psychological well-being. Accepting these emotions doesn’t mean wallowing in them, but rather acknowledging their presence and finding constructive ways to address them.

How to Cultivate Healthy Positivity

1. Acknowledge All Emotions

• Instead of forcing yourself to be happy all the time, give yourself permission to feel. Recognize that all emotions, even the uncomfortable ones, have a purpose. For example, fear can help us avoid danger, and sadness can indicate the need for change.

2. Practice Self-Compassion

• Being kind to yourself involves more than just positive affirmations. It means accepting where you are, even if it’s not a positive place. Self-compassion has been linked to better mental health outcomes, according to research in the Clinical Psychology Review (Neff, 2003).

3. Seek Realistic Optimism

Love

• Realistic optimism involves maintaining hope while accepting reality. It’s about saying, “This is hard, but I believe I can get through it.” It’s a healthier approach that acknowledges challenges while focusing on potential solutions.

4. Encourage Open Conversations

• If a friend or loved one is struggling, avoid jumping straight to positive reassurances. Instead, listen actively and validate their feelings. Phrases like “That sounds tough. How can I support you?” can create a safe space for vulnerability and connection.

5. Embrace Vulnerability

• Author and researcher Brené Brown emphasizes that vulnerability is not weakness—it’s a source of strength and connection. Embracing vulnerability means being honest about how you feel, even when it’s uncomfortable.

Embrace Real Positivity, Not Toxic Positivity

It’s okay to aim for a positive mindset, but it’s equally important to honor your true emotions along the way. Life is complex, and so are our feelings. Striving for genuine positivity means embracing all parts of the human experience—the highs and the lows. So, the next time someone tells you to “just be happy,” remember that it’s perfectly okay to respond with, “Not today, and that’s okay.”

Embrace Real Positivity

By understanding the dark side of self-help and toxic positivity, we can foster healthier, more authentic emotional well-being—for ourselves and those around us.